This
type of a White Collar crime is carried out without using a gun or
assault and without entering a bank or a house. It requires a fair
degree of sophistication in replicating the identity documents and
signatures and understanding of the real estate conveyancing
procedures. The level of sophistication of the criminals in this area
is growing. The amounts that skilled fraudster can steal is typically
in the hundreds of thousands of dollars.
This
type of a crime is relatively a new phenomenon which has grown big in
the last about five years and the volumes of money lost is growing
rapidly each year. The arrival of Title Insurance has softened the
blow to the average citizen who owns a house and has taken Title
Insurance. Arrival of Title Insurance in Canada and its wide spread
use goes back only about ten years. It is not yet common for the older
home owners yet to have Title Insurance although such Title Insurance
is now available. Currently most lenders will expect Title Insurance
when they lend on the security of the property.
A
typical title theft is planned by the con artists with considerable
skill and knowledge of the real estate procedure in buying and selling
a property. It also requires the ability to obtain and copy the
identity documents of the victim. Fraudsters use many variations for
title and identity theft. In a typical scenario they create a
fictitious offer to buy property using false signatures and without
the knowledge of the real owner. With forged identity and employment
letters mortgage funds are obtained. The offer is taken to a lawyer to
carry out the transaction who unsuspectingly carries out an entire
transaction in the normal way. The proceeds of sale are then
transferred by the fraudster to his account and he disappears. Usually
the mortgage payments are made for a few months. The real owner comes
to know that his property has been sold out when the mortgage company
sends a notice of collection.
The
Lawyers, Police and the Government are just beginning to understand
the nature and extent of this problem which causes enormous losses to
those who are affected by this fraud. The lawyers are now being taught
how to identify such theft. In the past it was not the practice of the
lawyers to check out their own clients and their own identities
through citizenship card, health card or a photo identity like a
driver’s licence, but now it has become the norm. Checking the
clients own identity through the lawyers is now mandatory for most
lending institutions. Unfortunately, a few lawyers have also been
tempted by the potentially large sums that they can obtain from such
theft.
Title
Insurance is offered by several title Insurance Companies in Canada,
including First Canadian, Title Plus, and Stuart Title. Most of them
cover fraud. Title Insurance Companies now have more detailed
checklists they use and expect the lawyers to use to detect potential
theft. The losses to the Insurance Companies run into millions of
dollars and there is a need to create systems which can prevent theft
rather than compensate the victim and REOSS Corporation of Ontario has
designed such a system.
Insurance
Companies do not just dish out the payment for the loss until a lot of
procedures are followed which can be time consuming and expensive. If
you do not have Title Insurance the cost of restoring title back to
rightful owner can cost between CAD$15,000.00 to CAD$25,000.00.
Therefore the prevention of theft with modest cost makes sense.
The
Provincial Government recently changed the legislation to alleviate
the problem. Fines and sentences have been increased for such crimes
and restoration of the title is made somewhat easier. Ontario does
carry a Land Titles System and the compensation fund to compensate
where the title is incorrectly shown on the register. However, this
fund does not automatically pay to compensate the victim of such
crime.
REOSS
Corporation, a company based in Richmond Hill, Ontario, uses the state
of the art Theft Prevention Systems to prevent such crimes. REOSS
prevents identity theft with checking of the proper identification of
the person in the lawyer’s or lender’s office. The electronic
device uses a swipe card system to check the driver’s license which
is shown on the screen and matched with the information on the
government records. Where there is a discrepancy between the two red
marks light up to show changes made.
Where
the person is proposing to change title through a lawyer the scanned
and stored information can be checked by the lender and the Title
Insurance Company with an access given to them on the website. In
addition to the identity checking REOSS can also register a caution on
title at the request of the property owner who wishes to be protected
for a fee. The caution requires the party dealing with the property to
go through the checking procedures of REOSS Corporation to ensure that
the proposed transfer or mortgage is genuine.
It
is helpful for the public, lending institutions and Title Insurance
Companies to learn more about how these crimes can be prevented. It is
similar to the alarm system you install to stop the burglar. In title
theft and ID theft there is a need for more proactive measures to
prevent large losses currently taking place.
Previous
Columns
Jay
Chauhan is a mediator, senior lawyer based in Richmond Hill,
Ontario, near Toronto, and an Economist from The London School of
Economics. He is a graduate of the Berlin University in
Agricultural Economics. He has 34 years experience and writes on legal
matters. He received Canadian Journalists' and Writers' Club (CEJWC)
award for 2004 in the Internet category - Opinion - for his legal
columns in South Asian Outlook e-Monthly. His email address is: jaychauhan53@hotmail.com
. His website is: www.jaychauhan.com].